How to know which of your branches is actually making money
Most owners of two or more branches can tell you last month's total sales. Far fewer can say, with confidence, which branch made money and which one quietly lived off the others. The busiest branch is often assumed to be the best one. It is not always so.
Sales are not profit
A branch earns its keep only after three things are taken from its sales: what the goods cost, what the branch itself costs to run, and the salaries of the people in it. Until you take all three from each branch separately, you are looking at a blend.
Here is a worked example with three branches of the same business in one month.
| Branch | Sales | Cost of goods | Rent and running | Salaries | Profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Town | 18,000 | 12,600 | 1,900 | 2,700 | 800 |
| Mall | 11,000 | 7,400 | 900 | 1,500 | 1,200 |
| Station | 9,000 | 6,500 | 1,300 | 1,900 | (700) |
Town sells the most and looks like the star. Mall, with barely more than half of Town's sales, makes more profit, because its rent is low and its team is small. Station loses 700 a month, and in the blended total nobody sees it: the business as a whole still shows a profit of 1,300.
Three figures to keep for every branch
- Gross profit: sales less the cost of what was sold. This needs a stock count at month end; without one you only know what was bought.
- The branch's own costs: its rent, electricity, salaries. Not a share of head office, just what would stop if the branch closed.
- Break-even sales: the sales the branch needs to cover those costs. If Station keeps 28 of every 100 it sells and costs 3,200 a month to run, it needs about 11,400 in sales. It is doing 9,000.
What to do with the losing branch
Before any talk of closing it, ask in this order. Is the margin being lost to discounts, expired stock or theft? Is the branch carrying a cost it does not need, such as a third staff member on quiet days? Is the rent out of line with the trade? Only when those have honest answers does closing become the right question.
And give the manager the figure. A branch manager who can see their own break-even every morning behaves differently from one who is told at month end that things were "a bit slow".